A Subway Anecdote That Doesn’t Involve the L Train

I was heading to Prospect Park last Friday night on the almost-as-dreaded-as-the-L F Train when a series of unusual events took place.

ftrain1.jpgIt began as a very usual event at East Broadway. I hate reinforcing stereotypes, but it’s a well-known fact that most residents of Chinatown simply ignore the rules and courtesies of the subway. Friday evening was no different. A middle-aged Asian woman dashed down the stairs into the train and held the door while she waited for her other middle-aged friend to mosey down the stairs behind her to get on the train.

This event caught the attention of a rather crazy older man on the train. Perhaps “crazy” is too extreme. I’ll go with “slightly imbalanced” instead. Actually, we’ll call him “The Enforcer” from here forward. By the time it was clear that she was holding the doors, this man turned to the Asian woman and began yelling at her.

“Don’t hold the doors,” he demanded. She continued to hold them. He raised his voice. “DO NOT HOLD THE DOORS!” Still, she persisted, ignoring The Enforcer. “CAN’T YOU READ THE SIGN?” From his seat, he pointed up towards the sign at the top of every subway door that says “Do Not Hold Doors.” She still held them. “STOP HOLDING THE DOORS! YOU’RE HOLDING EVERYONE UP!” The Enforcer flailed his arms in the air until the woman’s friend made it into the train. The doors closed, the women sat down, and the train pulled away.

donotholddoors.jpgBut the craz – err, imbalanced – man persisted. He got up from his seat and confronted the two women. It was clear to everyone on the train, him included, that his message wasn’t getting through to the women because of a language barrier. “LOOK. AT. THE. SIGN.” The Enforcer snapped, now putting his finger directly on the sign on the doors. “DO NOT HOLD THE DOORS!” Everyone on the train cackled at his booming voice. In fact, the sound of his voice alone made a baby in our car cry.

Two stations later, at Jay Street, a young man became another unfortunate victim of The Enforcer after holding the door for two seconds to get into the train. “Don’t hold the doors,” he shouted. “You’re holding up the train! It says it right there. Don’t hold the doors!” This man’s efforts to ignore The Enforcer were fruitless, much to the amusement of everyone else in the train.

A woman who got on at Jay Street with the door-holder sighed at the man’s shouting. The couple sitting next to her chuckled. “You think this is bad? You should’ve heard him in Manhattan!”

He kept quiet for the rest of the ride out to Prospect Park, but the conductor’s frustration boiled over a couple stops later at Carroll Street:

“This is Carroll Street. This is a Coney Island-bound F Train… the next stop is Smith & Ninth Street. Stand clear of the closing doors, please.”

[Subway doors remain open for at least 45 seconds.]


[Doors close.]

I can’t really blame them. The Enforcer and The Conductor were just both looking out for us lowly passengers, held hostage on a stalled-out train by a few inconsiderate straphangers. They just had no tact at all. At least we know their hearts were in the right place.



Filed under Life in NYC

7 responses to “A Subway Anecdote That Doesn’t Involve the L Train

  1. The worst is when you’re late to work because some dumbass holds the doors open for, like, 5 minutes. And it always happens when I oversleep (which, actually, is pretty much every morning).

  2. try the 4, grasshopper, try the 4.

  3. Dude, fuck tact. The Enforcer and The Conductor are my new heroes. I will emulate them on all further subway excursions.

  4. Ohh when people are blatant about it, you have every right to go completely ape shit on them. Go nuts.

  5. Gwin

    I don’t blame “The Enforcer” at all. And yeah, the Chinese (at the Grand and East Broadway stops) have the WORST subway etiquette: crowding the stairway so that no one trying to come down them has a chance of getting on the train, and pushing their way onto the train as soon as the doors open (without letting anyone out).

    I learned how to say “please stand aside” in Mandarin just so I could get out of the fuckin’ D, but that doesn’t seem to work very well either so I just shove ’em out of my way.

  6. Heh. OK you think the Chinatown subway stops are bad? Try walking in Chinatown, or rather, don’t ever try it unless you want to get enraged among the super crowdation the nth time some guy yells Chinese in your ear to someone standing right next to him.
    Good meeting you at the nerd party a few weeks back!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s